Some have been pretentious and forced, likening the call of songbirds to the sounds of the muezzin or even to the greeting Eid Mubarak. That almost sounds like a politician or a mediocrity churning out a crowd pleaser. Others have been natural, inclusive and embracing.
I have to admit, I have wished everyone a happy Eid on purpose. I think in the light of the constant riling and inflaming that our politicians seem to indulge in, the least we can do is to be inclusive and rejoice in all happiness, no matter who is responsible for sending it to us.
One of the most beautiful Eid messages I read came from a friend who recalled how the actress Meena Kumari, a devout Muslim could not keep Roja, the day long fast when she became very ill. Her friend the poet and film director Gulzar, an equally devout Hindu then offered to keep the fast for her as long as she remained ill. He ended up doing this for three years, until Meena Kumari passed away!
![]() |
By Rochishnu Sanyal |
This is what we need to tell our people, both adults and children. Instead of dividing the world along narrow religious and language lines, we have to realise we are all the same. No one group has a monopoly on idiots or on good people. It is up to us to recognise each and give them their rightful place.
I was reminded this weekend away at camp once again, of what I tell my students when they ask me whether I believe in Ganesha or not. This is usually the older age groups and thus they are also able to appreciate what I mean when I say, 'I am spiritual but not religious,' without wanting me to clarify it. Perhaps it is not such a bad thing after all, a little less religion and a lot more spirituality might do us all some good.
The artwork is by Rochishnu Sanyal.
Hear Hear! I second you, Ruma mashi. i can't get over explaining my parents this very thing. that i am spiritual but not religious.
ReplyDeletebut you have to admit, we do love the fun-filled festivals...:)
Thanks Aamen, I love each and every festival too.....and still believe that there is nothing quite like Park Street on Christmas Eve.....:)
DeleteA "little less religion and a lot more spirituality might do us all some good." No doubt. All our problems in life are due to lack of harmony , love and to some extent money. Your anecdote of Guljar fasting for Meena Kumari is touching and inspiring. I agree with with you entirely when you mention that "It is up to us to recognise each and give them their rightful place" So be it.
ReplyDeleteAmalda, thanks for your words of encouragement!
DeleteThank you for yet another wonderful, inclusive post, making so many good points. I was especially moved by your anecdote of Gulzar fasting for Meena Kumari to the end of her life. Even reading it a second time, the next day, tears are flowing.
ReplyDelete